Report times don't match record times

I'm trying to figure out why when I run reports on Meetings or Calls for example, the times in the reports don't reflect the actual time of each record. If a Meeting had a start time of 9am, whenever a report is run to list Meetings the time shows to be 4am (all listing are off by 5 hours). This seems to have changed recently, maybe with an update. The same reports used to show the correct times. All Sugar users are in the same time zone.